Five extra years of practice equal a 16.7% raise in gross lifetime earnings, a 31% raise in wealth at retirement, and no change at all to the retirement date. The arithmetic, with the model.

Take two attendings who start at 35 with nothing invested. One earns $400,000 a year for 30 years and stops at 65. The other earns the same $400,000 for 35 years and stops at 70. The second earns $2 million more over the career, which is what the first would have earned from a raise of $66,667 a year. On that arithmetic, five more years of practice is worth a 16.7% raise.
That answer is right for one question and wrong for two others, and the two others are the ones a retirement plan runs on.
If the comparison is total dollars earned, five extra years is worth whatever fraction of the base career it adds. On a 30-year career it is 5/30, a 16.7% differential. On a 25-year career, 20%. On a 35-year career, 14.3%. A physician weighing a job that pays 10% more against one that keeps them practicing five years longer can settle this question on the back of an envelope: the longer career wins on gross earnings unless the differential exceeds the fraction.
A retirement plan does not run on gross earnings. It runs on what was saved and what the savings earned. Assume both physicians save 20% of gross, $80,000 a year, into a diversified portfolio returning 4% a year after inflation. After 30 years the first has $4.49 million. After 35 years the second has $5.89 million, 31.3% more. The extra five years add five deposits, and they also let the balance built over the first 30 years compound for five more. So counted in wealth at retirement, five years is worth a 31% raise, not a 17% one. The break-even differential is higher because a raise only adds to each year's deposit, while five more years add deposits and compounding both.
The table reads as the pay differential that would produce the same terminal wealth as five extra years, at a constant savings rate. At 4% real on a 30-year base, a job paying 25% more loses to a job that keeps you working five years longer. A job paying 40% more wins.
In dollars, at $80,000 a year and 4% real: 25 years of saving produces $3.33 million, 30 years $4.49 million, 35 years $5.89 million, 40 years $7.60 million. Each five-year block adds more than the one before, and the block from 30 to 35 adds $1.4 million, which at a 4% withdrawal is $56,000 a year for the rest of a life.
Now change the question to the one most physicians are asking, whether the higher income lets them stop sooner. Set the target at 25 times annual spending, the level that supports a 4% starting withdrawal. Hold the savings rate at 20% of gross and a 30% effective tax rate, so spending is the remaining 50%. Then run it across incomes.
The date does not move. A physician earning $1 million and one earning $300,000 reach 25 times their own spending in the same year, because both the savings and the target scale with income and the ratio between them is fixed by the savings rate. Income decides the size of the retirement. The savings rate decides its date.
Raising the savings rate from 20% to 25% moves the date five years. A pay differential, of any size, moves it zero years unless the raise goes into savings rather than spending, in which case it is the savings rate that moved.
Three things, depending on the question. As gross earnings, a 16.7% raise on a 30-year career. As wealth at retirement, a 31% raise at 4% real. As a retirement date, nothing, because the date is set by the fraction saved and not by the amount earned or the years worked past the target. A physician comparing two paths with different pay has to decide which of the three they are comparing before the arithmetic can answer.
Every version assumes the five years happen. A national survey of 971 clinically inactive physicians who finished residency between 2000 and 2022, fielded in 2024 and published in 2026, put their mean age at 48.1, against 57.1 in a comparable 2008 cohort; 44.7% cited the hassle factor and 44.5% said the work was too stressful. In a June 2026 Doximity poll of more than 600 physicians, 46% said they were considering early retirement, up from 34% a year earlier. The five years at the end of a career are the five most likely not to occur, and on the evidence, the physicians who leave early are out of practice by their late forties, not at 65.
That reverses the question. A physician who plans on 35 years and delivers 30 has not lost a 16.7% raise; they have lost 24% of the wealth the 35-year plan counted on, and if their savings rate was set assuming those years, the target is not reached at all. The arithmetic of career length is the same arithmetic in both directions. It is the input that moves the result most, and the one a calculator asks the user to type in as if it were known.
In microsurgery and hand surgery, when a surgeon steps back from free-flap and replant call depends on health and interest, not a specific age. We often think about it in the same terms as retirement. Sixty is a round number to start thinking about it, but the decision can come sooner or later depending on the other factors.
The savings rate calculator takes your income, career stage and current savings and returns the rate that reaches a 25× target on your timeline. Run it at your planned retirement age, then run it again five years earlier and read the difference in the required rate.
The model is an illustration, not a projection for you and not advice. It uses a flat 30% effective tax rate, a constant real return with no sequence risk, no employer retirement contributions, no student debt, no Social Security, and spending that scales with income. It counts wealth in today's dollars, so the 4% figure is a real return. Adding Social Security and progressive tax rates moves most of the dates earlier and keeps the dates for all five incomes within two years of one another. The model is a Python script with its assumptions stated at the top, and the figures on this page are its output.
The Income Variable builds the plan on the input this page ends with: how long the income lasts, what shortens it, and what a plan looks like when the career is fifteen years instead of thirty. The career-stage playbook sequences it for early, mid and late career. Join the launch list for the book and the free companion tools.
This article is general information and analysis, not individualized medical, financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. See the Disclaimers page for the full statement.
Double board-certified reconstructive surgeon in Austin, Texas. Author of The Income Variable.
About the author
Join the launch list for book updates, new articles, and free companion tools.
By submitting, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge our Privacy Policy.